Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Health Care Story of the Week - 9/9/09

“Last Thursday, September 3, was the three year anniversary of Dylan’s wreck. That day, I told Dylan’s story in front of a 400-person crowd in Murfreesboro. It was my way of honoring my son and helping move our country toward a health system that cares for all Americans.” – Dottie Cordle

Dylan Cordle was born and raised in Middle Tennessee, but he was forced to leave his home in order to get medical care. At age 17, a senior in high school, Dylan suffered a traumatic brain injury in a motor vehicle accident. He was in a coma for four months, but eventually came to, and began therapies to help him regain life skills. A little over 2 years post-accident, Dylan completed high school and received his diploma.

During Dylan’s slow recovery, his mother Dottie Cordle was there for him each step of the way. Dottie owns a small embroidery shop called “Eye for Sewing,” and juggling a business and her son’s medical care became more than a full time job.

Dylan had private insurance through his mother’s work, and also qualified for TennCare. Even with two insurance plans, Dylan was unable to get the care he needed in Tennessee. Although children under 21 on TennCare are by law supposed to receive all medically necessary care, Dylan was turned down for acute inpatient rehabilitation which his doctors prescribed. Dottie fought TennCare to cover the service, but she lost.

Likewise, Dylan’s eye doctor said that he clearly needed neuro-rehabilitation, but many insurers, including TennCare routinely deny it, calling it “experimental.” Meanwhile, Medicare recognizes the treatment as safe, and with this treatment, his doctor thinks Dylan would have been better able to perform basic daily activities.

Without the medical care he needed, Dylan’s progress slowed. He remained unable to care for himself, and was socially isolated from his peers. His family and his doctors knew it was not a physical limitation that was holding Dylan back, but an insurance one.

Then, Dottie heard that Kentucky has a traumatic brain injury program for kids like Dylan. Since Dylan’s grandmother lives in Kentucky, the family made the difficult but clear decision to move Dylan out of state for treatment.

The care Dylan had fought so hard for in Tennessee but was unable to get was readily available across state lines. Dylan has already been in the program for about one month and is making progress. In addition to getting the therapies and doctor visits he needs, he participates in community outings with other individuals with brain injuries.


In Tennessee with TennCare, Dylan could not get the care that doctors ordered for him. A few hours away, getting the care he needs is easy. Ms. Cordle thinks there is something wrong with this picture. Her family has been in Tennessee for since 1984, and Dylan was born and raised here, yet he had to leave to get care. “Tennessee ought to provide its children with the best chance to reach their potential,” she said, “or else we risk pushing our kids out of state and draining Tennessee of its most valuable natural resource.”

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Video Conference for Advocates and Consumers 9/17/09 (rescheduled date)

Were you, a loved one, or a patient/client in the Daniels class and now being cut off TennCare?

September 17 (rescheduled date) you're invited to join an expert panel on at 9:30 Central/ 10:30 Eastern Time for a 1.5 hour video conference. The conference, which will include time for questions, will tell you what you can do to keep TennCare if you are eligible. If you are not eligible, it will cover other options.

Please visit the TJC website again for instructions on how to sign in to the video conference and links to presentation materials.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Health Care Story of the Week - 9/2/09

Ann B., though sick, is full of life. Ann wants to live for her son, to see him go to college. She lives in Memphis with her husband and 18 year-old. Her husband is a military veteran and receives his health care through the VA, and her son, who will graduate high school this year, is on TennCare. These programs help her husband, who is 67 years old, nearly blind, on oxygen, and barely able to walk and her healthy son get the medical care they need. Ann, however, was recently cut from TennCare due to a change in the program’s eligibility categories. TennCare sent a list of private companies from which Ann could purchase insurance. She called them all, and the lowest monthly premium was $600, almost 30% of the family’s monthly income, and much more than they can afford.

Ann relies on about 15 medications daily, as well as regular lab visits and doctor’s appointments to stay healthy enough to care for her son, husband, and herself. She suffers from rheumatoid arthritis, and without a chemotherapy medicine and regular lab checks, she would not be able to bathe, brush her teeth, cook, write, or drive. With the medication, she can do all of these things. Ann also has thyroid disease, congestive heart failure, blood clots, anemia, and other serious conditions, all of which require medicines and ongoing medical treatment.

She’s 62 years old – too young for Medicare – and she cannot get onto the Medicare program through a disability determination because she stopped working due to illness one quarter too early to qualify. Ann is calling prescription assistance programs, calling her elected officials, and telling her story to the media in hopes that someone will help her get her medicines and afford the doctor’s visits. But, Ann feels hopeless, as if there is no help to be found. She says that losing her TennCare is like a “sentence to die.”

Right now, Ann is completely out of her chemo pills and is already foregoing care. The household relies entirely on the fixed retirement income of less than $25,000 per year. After paying their house note, utilities, and gas, there’s virtually nothing left. They applied for Food Stamps, but were a few dollars over the limit. Ann knows from previous experience what it feels like to choose between food and medicines. She said that “when your stomach is grumbling, you’ll always choose the peanut butter sandwich over a pill.”

Ann is one of the thousands of Tennesseans who have fallen into the cracks in the health care system. She warns others, “don’t get sick like me,” for there may be little help to be found. For now, Ann looks for help wherever she can, and wonders why the richest country on earth continues to leave behind its own citizens.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Health Care Story of the Week - 8/26/09

Brandon has two young sons, ages 11 and 5. In 2004, he was playing with his son on a trampoline when a fall caused severe injuries to his spine. A quadriplegic as a result of this accident, Brandon now relies on TennCare-provided nurses and aides to care for him. Brandon went from working full time with his father as an industrial laborer, to needing constant care. In his words, he “depends on someone else’s hands” for everything he does. He also has a tracheostomy, which causes breathing problems and requires skilled care. Brandon is an active father despite his disabilities, and enjoys spending time with his sons. He’s also a college student, and is in the middle of his fifth term towards a degree in Business and Accounting. The one-on-one attention that his nurses and aides provide is working miracles for his health, and Brandon is slowly regaining some movement in his left arm.

A change to TennCare’s home health policies last fall, and the disappearance of a TennCare eligibility category, now threaten the life that Brandon has built since his accident. Essentially, TennCare is now requiring Tennesseans who need extensive care to make do with a dramatic reduction in home health hours or go into nursing homes, where the care would ostensibly be cheaper. Adding insult to injury, Brandon may lose his TennCare altogether because TennCare closed the category of eligibility Brandon qualified for.

Brandon says that there is more to care than its price tag, and his doctors agree that Brandon’s health would suffer in a nursing home. His tracheostomy requires frequent suctioning, and his doctors fear that he wouldn’t get the attention needed to keep him safe in a nursing home. Brandon lives with his grandmother, who does what she can to help, but is not physically able or properly trained to keep her grandson healthy and safe. Without constant in-home care, Brandon will be forced into a nursing home, to drop out of school, and to leave the community where his sons live. If Brandon loses his TennCare entirely, he’ll lose all his services and be left with no option but institutionalization, all before his 30th birthday.

The cuts that threaten Brandon’s family are in stark contrast to the recent promises to increase home and community based services for disabled Tennesseans. Cutting disabled individuals from TennCare flies in the face of the national movement to provide quality affordable choices for all Americans. Tennessee ranks among the worst states for home and community based options. Solutions such as the Long Term Care Choices Act were touted as improvements that would help keep families like Brandon’s together. Unfortunately, the State has not honored its promises, and many families now find themselves with no choice but to split up or face inadequate care. Likewise, the state has promised for years to open the Standard Spend Down program, a way for people losing TennCare to get back on if their medical bills are nearly equal to their monthly income. Still, the program remains closed, TennCare retains a surplus of millions of dollars, and Tennesseans like Brandon suffer.

Determined to keep his family together and to stand up for disabled parents across Tennessee, Brandon contacted the Tennessee Justice Center (TJC). With the help of TJC and Memphis attorney Linda Casals, Brandon is fighting his home health cuts in Chancery Court. Brandon has shared his story with legislators on the State and Federal level, and continues to be a strong advocate for all families struggling with health care issues. TJC recognized Brandon as a Father of the Year in 2009, and held a reception in Memphis in his honor.

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

New! Healthcare Story Series

Check our blog each week for a different health care story highlighting the current state of health care in Tennessee. Let us know what you think!

Health Care Story of the Week

Jennifer Perry is an energetic 32 year old. She volunteers at the Montgomery Christian Academy, where music students know her as “pretty Miss Jennifer.” Jennifer likes singing opera and art music, and has a Bachelor of Arts with a vocal concentration. Many of the people she met as President of the Handicap Educational Liaison Partners were surprised to learn that she is disabled, because she looks able-bodied and healthy. But Jennifer has advanced multiple sclerosis (MS), a disease that makes the brain and spinal cord unable to communicate with each other.

Jennifer had been on TennCare for about seven years when she received a letter that said she would be cut off later this month.

Among other symptoms, MS gives Jennifer blurry vision, numbness in her fingers, difficulty balancing, breathing, and moving, urinary and bowel difficulty, hypersomnia (similar to narcolepsy), hives, a weak immune system, severe allergies, muscle spasms, chronic pain, severe migraines, blackouts, mood disorder, and depression. She has had to have her front teeth replaced multiple times due to falling, and was recently forced to quit her job at a household appliance store because her symptoms were getting so bad.

Due to the two year waiting period, Jennifer will not be eligible for Medicare until late 2010. Without TennCare or Medicare, she will not be able to afford most of the roughly 25 medications she needs to remain stable. Her medications cost about $60,000 per year, but her annual income is below $10,000. “If I don’t have my medicine, something bad is going to happen to me,” she said.

Despite her disability, Jennifer worked from age 16 until just a few months ago, when her symptoms got so bad that she was forced to stop. Then, Jennifer’s father passed away suddenly. This and her escalating symptoms made her decide to move in with her elderly mother, who is also disabled. But Jennifer’s troubles weren’t over yet. Soon afterwards, she received the letter about her TennCare ending. Jennifer and her mother pray that Jennifer will find some way to get the health care her life depends upon.

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

TJC's Emily Einstein Shares Her Thoughts


I’m a paralegal/client-advocate at the Tennessee Justice Center. One of my duties includes taking calls from Tennesseans who are having trouble getting medically necessary services through TennCare. I listen to their stories and then help them get the services they need. By the time Ms. Dixon called me about helping her get Terrell’s wheelchair, she was worn out with trying to carry Terrell and all of his heavy medical machinery to doctors appointments. After we spoke, I helped her file a TennCare appeal and wrote a letter on Terrell’s behalf to the State’s attorneys. Later, I contacted the wheelchair company every few days until the wheelchair was delivered.

This was my first client success story since I started working at TJC. It felt so good to be able to help a child in need get a service that allows him to live a better life. When Ms. Dixon called me about the wheelchair, it had been months since the doctor had ordered the wheelchair but it still had not been delivered. I thought how difficult it must have been to have a sick child to transport without the aid of a wheelchair. Terrell definitely needed a wheelchair and I was glad that I could help him get one.

Working for TJC has opened my eyes to how hard it is for many children in Tennessee to get the medical services they need. Some of these families give up hope once their child is denied a service; I’m thankful that TJC steps in for families who are exhausted of fighting for care. Being a part of helping children, like Terrell, get services has been so meaningful.